Context map of 46 SHORE RD, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY, 11724 with nearby amenities

Real Report Card™

powered by RealHomeIntel

46 SHORE RD, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY, 11724

Huntington Town, NY, 11724

At a Glance

C+78/100
📍Location Check

Some amenities nearby, but not everything

A few essentials within reach, though some errands will require more of a drive.

🏠 Location is neutral — nothing flagging as a problem, nothing pricing as a premium.

💰Price Check

Hard to judge pricing

Priced about 31% above 7 recent comparable sales.

🏠 In-range on comps — where inside the range it lands is a condition question.

📊Market Demand

High owner occupancy in this area

97% of homes are owner-occupied — relatively high for this ZIP.

🏠 Homes clearing in ~79.47 days — that's a seller's market signal.

🌿Environmental Risk

High radon risk — testing recommended

This is worth factoring into your decision — review details in the full report below.

🏠 Zone 1 radon area — testing is non-negotiable at inspection. Mitigation is usually a few hundred dollars if needed.

🏠Property Fit

Some features are unusual for the area

large lot (2+ acres). Broad averages may be less reliable for this property.

🏠 Acreage fit is as much about what's possible on the land — outbuildings, privacy, subdivide potential — as it is about the home itself.

What to Verify Next

  • Get a CMA from a local agent before making an offer
  • Request a radon test during your inspection period
  • Confirm permit history with the county
  • Review recent nearby closed sales

Neighborhood comp range

$1,595,000 – $1,949,000

Based on limited comparable sales — verify with a local CMA

Based on 4 recent comparable sales nearby

LowMidpointHigh
$1,595,000$1,949,000

What Stands Out

Red Flags

Watch List

Confidence Signals

Looking at this property as an investment?

Run this address through the Investment Analyzer to estimate rent, expenses, cash flow, and long-term return.

Analyze This Property as an Investment

We'll use this address as a starting point. You can adjust price, rent, and assumptions.

$985,000

Last Sale Price

Property Snapshot

Property TypeSingle Family
Lot Size4.30 acres
Last Sale Price$985,000
Last Sale DateJanuary 3, 2018

Market Context

Median Home Value (ZIP)$1,480,400
Median Household Income$250,001
Income vs National3.3x national average
Estimated Monthly Mortgage$7,486/mo (est. 6.5%, 20% down)
Owner-Occupied97%
Renter-Occupied3%
Vacancy Rate8%

Risk & Safety

D
FEMA Flood ZoneZone Not Mapped — Minimal flood risk
Radon RiskZone 1 — High risk, testing recommended

Schools & Education

Assigned School DistrictCold Spring Harbor Central School District

School assignment may vary — confirm with the district directly

Nearby Public Schools

COLD SPRING HARBOR HIGH SCHOOL0.5 mi
GOOSEHILL PRIMARY CENTER0.9 mi
WEST SIDE SCHOOL1.4 mi
LLOYD HARBOR SCHOOL1.9 mi
SOUTHDOWN SCHOOL1.9 mi

Nearby Private Schools

ST PATRICK'S SCHOOL1.8 mi
EAST WOODS SCHOOL2.3 mi
THE CENTER FOR DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES2.9 mi
ST DOMINIC ELEMENTARY SCHOOL3.3 mi
ST DOMINIC HIGH SCHOOL3.3 mi

Nearby Colleges & Universities

SUNY Old Westbury7.6 mi
Farmingdale State College8.4 mi
Monroe University16.6 mi
Purchase College17.3 mi
Queens College, City University of New York20.8 mi

Location Check

C+
Nearby AmenitiesData temporarily unavailable — re-run report for full results

Environmental Risk

A-
Air Quality (AQI)AQI 57 — Moderate
Superfund Sites in ZIPNone — Clean
Toxic Release FacilitiesNone — Clean
Elevation7 ft above sea level
Solar Potential4.0 kWh/m²/day avg

Neighborhood

MunicipalityHuntington Town
Population (ZIP)2,874
Median Age38.5 years
College Educated (%)39% with bachelor's or higher
Work From Home26% of workers
Families with Children48% of families
Median Year Homes Built1958
CountySuffolk County

Market Snapshot — ZIP 11724

Recent market data for this ZIP code

$2,300,000

Median Sale Price (ZIP)

$6,450/mo

Median Rent

79.47 days

Avg Days on Market

15

Active Listings

Property DetailsTax, construction, utilities & more

Tax Assessed Value$7,150
Tax — Land Value$3,900
Tax — Improvements$3,250
Annual Tax Amount$28,951
Effective Tax Rate404.91%
Elevation7 ft
Solar Potential (GHI)4.0 kWh/m²/day
CountySuffolk County
MunicipalityHuntington Town

Recent Comparable Sales (5)

Median $/SqFt: $546
Avg $/SqFt: $539

Based on 4 recent comparable sales. Reasonable directional indicator.

1352 RIDGE RD, SYOSSET, NY 11791

3 bed · 2 bath · 3,199 sqft · Built 1913

$1,495,000

$467/sqftSold Aug 2025

10 ERICK CT, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY 11724

4 bed · 2.5 bath · 2,126 sqft · Built 1958

$1,350,000

$635/sqftSold Jul 2025

31 TURKEY LN, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY 11724

3 bed · 2 bath · Built 2016

$893,000

Sold Jul 2025

1384 RIDGE RD, SYOSSET, NY 11791

4 bed · 2 bath · 2,152 sqft · Built 1962

$925,000

$430/sqftSold Jul 2025

2 MOWBRAY LN N, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY 11724

6 bed · 6.5 bath · 8,000 sqft · Built 2007

$4,995,000

$624/sqftSold Apr 2025

Sale History

November 8, 2017

DE

$985,000

Construction & Features

Garage: No
Pool: No

Tax & Assessment

$1,300,000

County Market Value (2023)

$7,150

Assessed Value (2025)

Building: $590,909 · Land: $709,091

Ownership & Liens

Owner: GAGNON FAMILY TRUST; NICHOLAS SANDERS
Owned since: November 2017
Est. equity: $1,687,469
🏆

What Stands Out

This property at 46 SHORE RD, COLD SPRING HARBOR, NY, 11724 received an overall grade of C+.

💪 Working in Your Favor

  • Minimal flood risk (Zone Not Mapped)
  • No Superfund or toxic release sites in this ZIP
  • Median household income $250,001 in this ZIP
  • Spacious lot — 4.3 acres of land
  • 97% owner-occupied homes in this ZIP
  • 39% of residents hold a bachelor's degree or higher
  • Cold Spring Harbor Central School District
  • Located in Huntington Town

👁️ Worth Checking

  • Radon Zone 1 — testing recommended before purchase

Agent's Comments

From the mind of a top producing real estate agent

This is just a range of potential value — $1.6M to $1.9M. We had limited comparable sales to work with, so treat this as a strong starting point — not a final answer. If the property needs a lot of work, it would sit at the lower end — and we can position it for a cash investor. If it has all the upgrades — new kitchen, updated baths, hardwood floors, a screened-in porch, pool, or other features we can't see in this report — it could push the value well above this range. That's what a walk-through tells us that the data can't. Properties like this are harder to comp — every one is unique. The data gives us a baseline, but the real value comes down to the walk-through and what a buyer is willing to pay for the features that make this one special.

These highlights are generated from public data, comparable sales, and environmental records — not a formal appraisal. A walk-through and local agent analysis are always recommended.

Your Market Snapshot

Using 7 recent comparable sales as a reference, the estimated value is approximately $1,772,000. Comparable homes in the area are trading at a median of $546 per square foot.

Looking at the broader market, Homes in ZIP 11724 are sitting on the market longer than usual, averaging 79 days, and the median sale price sits at $2.3M.

Worth noting: high radon risk and vacancy above average. On the positive side, minimal flood risk.

Have a question about this property or the surrounding area? Our AI assistant below has full context on this report and can help you dig deeper.

Do you have questions about 46 SHORE RD, COLD SPRING HARBOR?

Ask me! I know the data on this property, neighborhood, and market.

Real Home Intel AI may make mistakes. Verify important information independently.

This is not an appraisal. Data sourced from public records and verified APIs.

Grades reflect environmental data, infrastructure, and public services. They do not reflect or consider the demographic composition of any area.

See an error?

Compare Another Address

Run a free report on any U.S. property

Save This Report

Get a link to this report emailed to you — free, no account needed

Data sourced from U.S. Census Bureau, FEMA, EPA AirNow, EPA Envirofacts, NCES, USGS, NREL, HUD, FCC, NOAA, EIA, Walk Score, RentCast, OpenStreetMap, Census Geocoder, Realie.Report generated 4/16/2026.

← Run Another Report