SOLD: 5620 Islington Ave, Madisonville (45227) sold for $300,000. Fully updated 1924 Tudor. The Tye Group represented seller Steve and buyers Chris and Kate.
Quick Answer
5620 Islington Avenue in Madisonville, OH 45227 sold for $300,000 on October 16, 2026. That's 101.7% of its final list price of $295,000, with 35 days from listing to closing. Derek Tye and The Tye Group (Coldwell Banker Realty) represented both the seller and the buyer. The 2-bedroom property is in Cincinnati Public Schools.
Sale at a Glance
- Sold price: $300,000
- Original list price: $334,900
- Final list price: $295,000
- Sale-to-list ratio: 101.7%
- Closed: October 16, 2026
- Listing to closing: 35 days
- Previous recorded sale: $91,000 (2019)
- The Tye Group: Represented both the seller and the buyer
- Location: 5620 Islington Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45227 (Madisonville, Hamilton County)
- School district: Cincinnati Public Schools
- MLS #: 1893337
How did we represent both sides on 5620 Islington Avenue?
This is the third Madisonville home we've sold this fall for our repeat investor client Steve. He renovates the right way, with new electric, plumbing, HVAC and windows, and buyers can tell. Chris and Kate, who had already bought 139 Winkler St with us, came back and bought this one. We represented both sides and closed October 16, 2026 at $300,000.
What stood out about 5620 Islington Avenue?
- 1924 Tudor-style home, completely updated
- New electric, plumbing, HVAC, windows and flooring; roof 2015, garage door 2022
- Kitchen with Keidel cabinets, quartz, gas range and built-in coffee bar
- Two bedrooms and a walk-in-shower bath on the main level
- Waterproofed, finished walkout lower level with 22x24 rec room, 2nd full bath and laundry (about 1,566 finished sq ft total)
- Covered front porch, tiled fireplace, attached garage
Madisonville Is Moving
Between Oakley, Mariemont and Kenwood, with quick access to Red Bank and I-71, Madisonville keeps drawing buyers priced out of its neighbors. See Steve's other two sales this fall: 4425 Homer Ave and 6823 Roe St.
How does this sale compare to the Greater Cincinnati market?
Across Greater Cincinnati in August 2026, the median sale price was about $287,000, homes averaged 49 days on market, and sold for 98.7% of list price (Redfin data, as reported in The Tye Group's October 2026 market update). 5620 Islington Avenue closed at 101.7% of its final list price, 3.0 points above the metro average. Since its 2019 sale at $91,000, the property's recorded price is up 230%.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did 5620 Islington Avenue sell for?
5620 Islington Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45227 sold for $300,000 on October 16, 2026. The final list price was $295,000, a 101.7% sale-to-list ratio.
Who was the real estate agent for 5620 Islington Avenue?
Derek Tye of The Tye Group, Coldwell Banker Realty, represented both the seller and the buyer of 5620 Islington Avenue. Derek has 22+ years of experience and about 1,785 homes sold.
How long did it take to sell 5620 Islington Avenue?
It took 35 days from the first list date (September 11, 2026) to closing (October 16, 2026).
What school district is 5620 Islington Avenue in?
5620 Islington Avenue is in Cincinnati Public Schools. Always verify school assignment with the district before buying.
What is my Madisonville home worth?
Every home is different. Condition, lot, updates and timing all move the number. The Tye Group prepares free, no-pressure valuations using recent closed sales like this one. Contact Derek Tye through his RealHomeIntel profile.
About Derek Tye
Derek Tye leads The Tye Group with Coldwell Banker Realty (Coldwell Banker Global Luxury) in Loveland, Ohio. He has 22+ years in real estate, about 1,785 homes sold, and ranks in the top 2% of Coldwell Banker agents globally. He is a Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist and also invests in residential, short-term-rental and mixed-use commercial property, so he looks at every deal from both an agent's and an owner's point of view. He serves Greater Cincinnati, including Loveland, Symmes Township, Montgomery, Madeira, Mason, Milford, Anderson, Madisonville and the surrounding counties.
Thinking About Selling or Buying in Madisonville?
If you're curious what your Madisonville home would sell for today, or want help winning the next one, reach out for a no-pressure conversation.
Last updated November 2026.
Sale data via CincyMLS and public records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity.